Did ‘Saturday Night Live’ Go Too Far in Its Tiger Woods Skit?

“Saturday Night Live”has drawn praise for an episode (hosted by the “Gossip Girl” star Blake Lively) that opened with a satire on Michaele and Tareq Salahi, the Virginia couple accused of crashing President Obama’s first state dinner. But the show took criticism for a skit that tweaked Tiger Woods and the speculation about marital difficulties between him and his wife, Elin, since his car accident late last month.

In the comedy sketch, Tiger Woods (played by the “S.N.L.” performer Kenan Thompson) gives a series of press conferences attempting to apologize for acts of infidelity. In each appearance, the fictional Woods appears with more bruises and injuries, evidently sustained at the hands of Elin (played in the skit by Ms. Lively).

Around the blogosphere, viewers wondered if “Saturday Night Live” went too far in mining comedy from the subject of domestic abuse — particularly when the show’s musical guest was Rihanna, who in February was assaulted by her then-companion, Chris Brown.

On the Web site TVSquad.com, Annie Wu wrote:

It’s another one of those strange double standard things; had the tables been turned and a man was suspected of beating up his wife, there definitely wouldn’t be a lighthearted sketch like this. But since it’s female-on-male domestic violence, our current culture deems it kind of, sort of O.K. to make fun of and the scandal had to be addressed before it lost heat. I don’t know, it’s touchy ground. I wouldn’t have thought twice about it if Rihanna wasn’t the musical guest.

The Web site Popeater.com was less ambivalent about the sketch, writing: “We think, had the genders been reversed, ‘SNL’ wouldn’t make light of the potentially violent situation — and with Rihanna on board, we wonder if a domestic violence gag was in especially poor taste.”

And Jezebel.com called the skit one of the night’s “obvious missteps,” adding sarcastically that the sketch was “a classy move when you consider that Rihanna was the night’s musical guest.”

What do you think? Is there a double standard at work in the “Saturday Night Live” skit? Should “S.N.L.” have avoided the subject because Rihanna was a guest, or should they have stayed away from it in all circumstances? Post a comment below and let us know.

Comments are no longer being accepted.

Let me find my pen. December 7, 2009 · 11:01 am

There is no too far for Tiger Woods.

It was the only funny skit of the night.

What’s the big deal? SNL has always been edgy. I don’t think anyone should be concerned that Tiger is helpless or trapped in his circumstances. Is there some other motive at play here other than concern about Tigers’ well-being?

Retired USMC officer December 7, 2009 · 11:10 am

Eldrick (Cheetah) Woods deserves to be pilloried for both his attitude and his actions. People made a hero out of this lout and he rewarded them with ugly behavior. The skit is right on target.

I cannot comment because I missed the show — but, frankly, while I am certain that the TW sketch went too far for some viewers, and its showing may have been in questionable taste given the musical guest, there is no question that whatever TW did or did not do in addition to crashing his car into a fire hydrant and tree, his inability or unwillingness to get in front of the story as quickly as possible opened the door to speculation and satire.

Another wealthy celebrity who cannot control his behavior or his public relations. Revolting.

What’s the big deal? SNL always goes a little too far. That’s why it has been so popular for years. Any thinking person takes it all with a few grains of salt.

There are always double standards when it comes to gender issues, but instances like this show much more misogyny than misandry. Our culture makes light on female to male domestic violence because men are seen as powerful and women are seen as fragile; it’s almost “adorable” when a wife physically acts out on her husband, and that’s something the sketch continues to put in our minds.

Domestic violence is domestic violence, whether committed by a woman or a man.

If Elin Woods did indeed commit domestic violence against her husband, then she should be hauled into court just like any male offender would be. And her fitness to be a parent to their children should be rigorously scrutinized, just as a male offender would be.

Rihanna’s presence on the show is a red herring — the above principle would continue to apply even if she hadn’t been on the show.

I wouldn’t know because after about 60 seconds–as much as I could bear–of the painfully unfunny skit about the White House crashers (yes, the one that has “drawn praise,” from who knows who), I switched the show off, as usual.

Saturday Night Live is lousy and embarrassing and I can’t believe people still try to make it a topic of conversation.

Oh come on please its just a sketch !
Get a real life journalists you can see this was greatly exaggerated and besides by the way he behaved for than once i think its excellent to poke fun at him.
Next time hell definitely keep his pants up and stop chasing other women specially since his wife is drop dead gorgeous .
I seriously think they are making fun at infidelity here not of domestic violence per se.

This sketch also would have been better if it was funny. The Underground Rock Festival sketch was the highlight of the night for me:
//bit.ly/7XYnO6

Get over it, it was hysterical. The number of women claiming to have had affairs with Woods is now up to 10. Elin Woods needs to get to the doctor, get a clean bill of health, gather up the kids, take her dog of a husband to court, secure a loarge divorce settlement and get the hell out of that sham of a marriage.

I thought the skit “Gossip Girl: Staten Island” would have raised more eyebrows. In one scene a woman confronts her husband in a pizzeria and smacks him hard in the face. He returns the favor with a punch in the eye after which they make up and kiss. Really SNL? With Rihanna as your musical guest?

For the past couple seasons, too many SNL skits revolve around pointless violence, kindergarten bathroom humor, or homophobic situational comedy.

But their worst crime of all is being horribly unfunny.

Comparing this to a real world situation of domestic abuse is silly.

If the genders were reversed AND the physical characteristics were reversed with a powerful buff strong ripped PROFESSIONAL ATHLETE woman in the same place not defending herself, not running away and continuing to try to explain and get into more trouble IT WOULD STILL BE FUNNY.

I think even Tiger and his wife would have to laugh at this. If not, maybe they should.

Come on, grow up. Girls can hit guys, and that is OK. Guys should never hit girls. Way it is and stop your crying like a little girl.

Let’s get this straight – some people in the blogosphere want SNL to be LESS edgy. Moving the dial from pablum to . . . what? . . . powdered milk?

hey why sugar coat it. Lest one be judged,by ones-self

The skit was funny and good entertainment. I find it amazing a liberal NY Times blog of all things is commenting on freedom of the press and whether its suitable to have a comedy sketch on this material. The Times itself has no problem leveraging the same right to blast people who thought global warming was a scam. Oh yea, it is.

THought the skit was spot on. He is a public person acting indescrimetly and has to accept responsibility.

I have not read any accounts of spousal abuse, just bizarre circumstance one night and a great many woman with stories of his sexual exploits. For one billion dollars of, mostly, promotional income, this just goes with his job. I, one the other hand, will not get paid anything to explain to my son why his idol is getting such unwanted publicity.

Are you serious?

I am sorry, the comic relief outweighs the politically correct portrayal of domestic abuse! Besides don’t you have any shame trying to suppress freedom of artistic and comic expression!

It was funny. Get over it. Our country is becoming too “sensitive” and “PC” to every issue. By poking fun at something that inheritantly is NOT funny, we just bring the issue to light.
Good job SNL, keep bringing the jokes and making us normal folk laugh.

Thought poor taste was a hallmark of “SNL.” Hasn’t been funny for years.