Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Question about wave action on inland lake.

1 view
Skip to first unread message

dh...@nomail.com

unread,
Apr 13, 2004, 6:57:34 PM4/13/04
to
Hi,

I have a boat on Lake Lanier in GA. The other morning I took it out,
and the overall wave action appeared to be different than usual.
It was a flat calm day, except when a passing boat produced some
waves. Most of the time the waves seem to be sort of peaked and
a bit sharp, but on this morning they were more rounded and flatter.
The first boat I noticed it from, I thought it might be simply due to
the shape of the boat itself. But after a while I noticed it was true of
all of them...which was cool with me because it meant I could go
faster without getting tossed in the air too much. It still made me
wonder *why* though. Could it have something to do with what
creates high and low tides, and/or why sometimes when you dig
a hole you seem to have more dirt than you took out and sometimes
you seem to have less? If so, is there a way to predict when waves
will tend to be sharper and when they will tend to be flatter, like
people can predict high and low tides?

Rick & Linda Bernard

unread,
Apr 13, 2004, 7:50:27 PM4/13/04
to
Was the water temperature different then normal? Both viscosity and surface
tension vary with water temp which may explain the differences.

Can't help you on the hole and dirt observation. Suggest you try the
gardening news group :-)


<dh...@nomail.com> wrote in message
news:5iro709vk46inb3df...@4ax.com...

Jim Irvine

unread,
Apr 13, 2004, 8:20:49 PM4/13/04
to
As I recall, wave shape, frequency and height is determined by the 3 main
factors of wind speed, fetch (distance of open water) and water depth. If
you have a shallow body of water with only a modest wind speed of 15 mph
over large fetch, such as the Chesapeake Bay, this will result in a constant
chop of waves very close together in frequency. Conversely, the same wind
speed over a smaller fetch, such as a deep inland lake, will produce smaller
waves that are shaped quite differently. The waves you mentioned are
produced by a boat rather than the wind, but I wonder if the same principles
apply here as well. Perhaps the water depth where you witness this wave
action was very deep and had an effect upon the wave shape.


<dh...@nomail.com> wrote in message
news:5iro709vk46inb3df...@4ax.com...

Wayne.B

unread,
Apr 13, 2004, 8:47:12 PM4/13/04
to
========================================

In general there seem to be two things that affect the shape of a
boats wake.

First is distance. The further you are from the boat that made the
wake, the less steep it wil become. Steep waves represent a lot of
energy, and the energy dissipates as the wave travels over a distance.

The other determinant is the type of boat and the speed it is
traveling. A fast boat traveling on plane will produce a steep
breaking wave directly behind the boat, with the height depending on
the weight of the boat and its hull shape. Large heavy boats that are
not yet on plane tend to produce a long gradual wake more like an
ocean swell.

Mark Borgerson

unread,
Apr 14, 2004, 10:39:59 AM4/14/04
to
In article <5iro709vk46inb3df...@4ax.com>,
dh...@nomail.com says...


I suspect that some of the differences in wave characteristics
you observe might be due to a very strong and shallow
thermocline in the lake. That might act as an artificially
shallow 'bottom' for the waves, changing their character.
At this time of the year, the lake is probably not too
stratified, and the real depth controls the waves.
Later in the summer, it may be very stratified, with
a sharp thermocline at 6 to 15 feet. (I've discovered
those when diving into apparently warm lakes!).

Another phenomenon which probably doesn't have much
to do with your observations is sieching. It is well
described at

http://www.glcclub.com/lifeline/03mar/seiches.htm

Small lakes don't usually have tides---but they can
have seiches, which can show some of the same
characteristics.

Whether it has anything to do with the amount of
dirt in holes, who knows. That phenomenon has
to do with relative compaction---a lesson I learned
as an enginering student trainee with the California
Dept. of Transportation many decades ago.


Mark Borgerson

Gary Warner

unread,
Apr 14, 2004, 10:55:57 AM4/14/04
to
Could it be...

+ There was something in the water, like more weads or growth, that kept the
waves from building?

+ There was oil on the water. I've heard that even a thin layer of oil will
effect wave action.

+ That normally, but not this day, there is some wind that catches even
little waves and makes them a little more pronounced?

+ That normally, but not this day, there are lots of other waves from either
wind or boats that cause interference with all
the waves and make them all more pronounced?

Just guessing around.


basskisser

unread,
Apr 14, 2004, 2:12:33 PM4/14/04
to

I fish Lanier, where on the lake are you?

Greg

unread,
Apr 13, 2004, 7:49:46 PM4/13/04
to
My guess is air temperature and pressure, and the water temperature.
Course, it could have been an oil slick too, or some other chemicals doing
the same thing.
Greg Luckett

<dh...@nomail.com> wrote in message
news:5iro709vk46inb3df...@4ax.com...


-----= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =-----
http://www.newsfeeds.com - The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World!
-----== Over 100,000 Newsgroups - 19 Different Servers! =-----

dh...@nomail.com

unread,
Apr 16, 2004, 9:39:03 AM4/16/04
to
On Wed, 14 Apr 2004 14:39:59 GMT, Mark Borgerson <m-a...@oes.to> wrote:

[...]


>Whether it has anything to do with the amount of
>dirt in holes, who knows. That phenomenon has
>to do with relative compaction---a lesson I learned
>as an enginering student trainee with the California
>Dept. of Transportation many decades ago.
>
>
>Mark Borgerson

Thank you. What influences relative compaction?

dh...@nomail.com

unread,
Apr 16, 2004, 9:41:35 AM4/16/04
to

At Holiday Marina. I don't fish, but if you'd want to hook up and go
for a boat ride--houseboat, runabout, and/or paddle around in a kayak
--let me know. So far I haven't met anyone from a news group, and
that would be cool for me. I'm at R17. Give me a call at 678-714-5764,
or an email at kl...@mindspring.com sometime if you want. If you send
an email be sure to mention something about Lanier or the like so I know
it's not spam, 'cause I get about a hundred spams a day.

basskisser

unread,
Apr 16, 2004, 1:51:22 PM4/16/04
to
dh...@nomail.com wrote in message news:<jiov70pea1vb1mfm4...@4ax.com>...

Cool, I'll do it. I sometimes put my bass boat in at Aqualand, but
mostly Shoal Creek. Holiday Marina is nice. Do you live on your
houseboat? I'll email you, possibly going fishing next weekend.

Jim Conlin

unread,
Apr 16, 2004, 4:42:06 PM4/16/04
to
There's a treatment of this subject in 'The American Practical Navigator' ('Bowditch').
Wave height and period are a function of wind strength and the time and distance that the wind has had to build them up.  If the fetch is across a large body of water, waves will be higher.  If the wind has only recently risen, the waves will be flatter. Rain smooths small waves further.  Icing smooths things, too.  If there's been a large wind shift, waves will be irregular.  Shallow water makes makes waves shorter and steeper.

Mark Borgerson

unread,
Apr 16, 2004, 6:10:39 PM4/16/04
to
In article <keov701oorkjtcp3b...@4ax.com>,
dh...@nomail.com says...
Going back a bit here:

1. type and size of material. It's hard to compact a pail of
marbles. But If you add a couple of cups of BBs, they will
disappear into the interstices between the marbles if you
shake the bucket. The same applies to soils and aggregate
mixes. With the proper ratios of fine and coarse materials
you can get better compaction. I spent a lot of time with
a sieve set and shaker determining the relative proportions
of fine and coarse materials in aggregate mixes.

2. Vibration and pressure. Rollers, thumpers and tampers
move the materials into the most dense (compact configuration).

3. Moisture. I guess the water helps the fine particles
infiltrate the interstices and makes it easier for
particles to move around. (It keeps down the dust
on the job site also.)


Mark Borgerson


dh...@nomail.com

unread,
Apr 16, 2004, 11:29:12 PM4/16/04
to

I wish.

>I'll email you,

Good deal.

>possibly going fishing next weekend.

Good luck...to you, not the fish :-)

Wilson Woods

unread,
Jun 7, 2004, 5:44:09 PM6/7/04
to
dh...@nomail.com wrote:

> On 14 Apr 2004 11:12:33 -0700, atl_...@yahoo.com (basskisser) wrote:
>
>
>>dh...@nomail.com wrote in message news:<5iro709vk46inb3df...@4ax.com>...
>>
>>>Hi,
>>>
>>>I have a boat on Lake Lanier in GA. The other morning I took it out,
>>>and the overall wave action appeared to be different than usual.
>>>It was a flat calm day, except when a passing boat produced some
>>>waves. Most of the time the waves seem to be sort of peaked and
>>>a bit sharp, but on this morning they were more rounded and flatter.
>>>The first boat I noticed it from, I thought it might be simply due to
>>>the shape of the boat itself. But after a while I noticed it was true of
>>>all of them...which was cool with me because it meant I could go
>>>faster without getting tossed in the air too much. It still made me
>>>wonder *why* though. Could it have something to do with what
>>>creates high and low tides, and/or why sometimes when you dig
>>>a hole you seem to have more dirt than you took out and sometimes
>>>you seem to have less? If so, is there a way to predict when waves
>>>will tend to be sharper and when they will tend to be flatter, like
>>>people can predict high and low tides?
>>
>>I fish Lanier, where on the lake are you?
>
>
> At Holiday Marina. I don't fish

Helping to prove, in part, that you don't care about
"decent lives" for animals, Fuckwit. You'd rather eat
grain-fed beef and cause countless collateral deaths of
animals in the field, than get your fat pimply ass out
of your busted-up barcalounger and catch a fish.

> but if you'd want to hook up and go
> for a boat ride--houseboat, runabout, and/or paddle around in a kayak
> --let me know. So far I haven't met anyone from a news group, and
> that would be cool for me. I'm at R17. Give me a call at 678-714-5764,

Fuckwit, who is Willie Denson, and why are you using
his phone number? http://tinyurl.com/2ms9e

Willie Denson

unread,
Dec 23, 2004, 12:17:18 PM12/23/04
to

Willie Denson

unread,
Dec 23, 2004, 12:18:21 PM12/23/04
to

Jay Santos

unread,
Dec 23, 2004, 12:20:51 PM12/23/04
to
Willie Denson wrote:


"Hook up", Fuckwit? Isn't that homo cracker slang for
"an episode of wild-eyed bungholery"?

Mr.Smartypants

unread,
Apr 25, 2011, 6:56:51 PM4/25/11
to
On 4/16/2004 6:41 AM, dh...@nomail.com wrote:
> On 14 Apr 2004 11:12:33 -0700, atl_...@yahoo.com (basskisser) wrote:
>
>> dh...@nomail.com wrote in message news:<5iro709vk46inb3df...@4ax.com>...
>>> Hi,
>>>
>>> I have a boat on Lake Lanier in GA. The other morning I took it out,
>>> and the overall wave action appeared to be different than usual.
>>> It was a flat calm day, except when a passing boat produced some
>>> waves. Most of the time the waves seem to be sort of peaked and
>>> a bit sharp, but on this morning they were more rounded and flatter.
>>> The first boat I noticed it from, I thought it might be simply due to
>>> the shape of the boat itself. But after a while I noticed it was true of
>>> all of them...which was cool with me because it meant I could go
>>> faster without getting tossed in the air too much. It still made me
>>> wonder *why* though. Could it have something to do with what
>>> creates high and low tides, and/or why sometimes when you dig
>>> a hole you seem to have more dirt than you took out and sometimes
>>> you seem to have less? If so, is there a way to predict when waves
>>> will tend to be sharper and when they will tend to be flatter, like
>>> people can predict high and low tides?
>>
>> I fish Lanier, where on the lake are you?
>
> At Holiday Marina. I don't fish, but if you'd want to hook up

What's that? You want to "hook up" with some guy on the lake? What's
that all about?


> and go
> for a boat ride--houseboat, runabout, and/or paddle around in a kayak
> --let me know.

Please don't tell us what you intend to do when you get back to the
houseboat.


> So far I haven't met anyone from a news group, and
> that would be cool for me. I'm at R17. Give me a call at 678-714-5764,

Hmmm...I've seen that number somewhere lately. I can't quite recall
where...

Mr.Smartypants

unread,
Apr 25, 2011, 6:59:12 PM4/25/11
to
On 4/13/2004 3:57 PM, dh...@nomail.com wrote:
> Hi,
>
> I have a boat on Lake Lanier in GA. The other morning I took it out,
> and the overall wave action appeared to be different than usual.
> It was a flat calm day, except when a passing boat produced some
> waves. Most of the time the waves seem to be sort of peaked and
> a bit sharp, but on this morning they were more rounded and flatter.
> The first boat I noticed it from, I thought it might be simply due to
> the shape of the boat itself. But after a while I noticed it was true of
> all of them...which was cool with me because it meant I could go
> faster without getting tossed in the air too much. It still made me
> wonder *why* though. Could it have something to do with what
> creates high and low tides, and/or why sometimes when you dig
> a hole you seem to have more dirt than you took out and sometimes
> you seem to have less?

You moron - if you dig a hole, there is exactly as much dirt outside the
hole as you dug out of it.


> If so, is there a way to predict when waves
> will tend to be sharper and when they will tend to be flatter, like
> people can predict high and low tides?

You're really a loose stool, Harrison.

Message has been deleted
0 new messages