Academia.eduAcademia.edu
Understanding Terrorism and Political Violence: The Life Cycle of Birth, Growth, Transformation, and Demise by Dipak K. Gupta. Abingdon: Routledge, 2008. 283pp., £22.99, ISBN 978 0 41577165 8. This well-written and useful book uses a multidisciplinary approach to analyse and conceptualise differing aspects of terrorism and political violence. The book is divided into nine chapters each offering, convincing, well-presented arguments relating to the motivations, undertaking and countering of terrorism and political violence. Gupta’s core claim is that the literature on terrorism and political violence, seems devoid of conceptual and theoretical consistency. The perceived and actual nature of terrorism suggests that studies that aim to provide such consistency should not be restricted to one particular discipline. To do this demonstrates a failure to appreciate the idiosyncratic nature of this form of violence within and between states. As such, Gupta draws on various disciplines including biology, criminology, economics, history, politics, social psychology and sociology to support his argument. The purpose of this work, therefore, is to provide a clear, logical, conceptual and theoretical framework upon which other studies may be built. Gupta himself looks at the origins behind terrorism, the relationship between faith, nationalism, class and terrorism as well as that which exists between terrorism and organised crime. Chapters 8 and 9 focus, primarily, on the manner in which terrorism and political violence can end. Gupta’s conclusion is that the study of terrorism is a combination of many disciplines. Consequently, in order to gain a clear understanding of any aspect of it one must be well versed in the various disciplines that this form of violence straddles. One specific issue that arises when reflecting upon this text is Gupta’s failure to engage fully in the definition debate within the terrorism discourse. By not doing so he detracts from his overall thesis regarding conceptual and theoretical consistency. This is because the absence of a universally accepted definition of this form of violence must surely affect the manner in which it is conceptualised and theorised within the literature. A more general criticism is the perhaps paradoxical problem of multidisciplinary approaches. Such approaches highlight the complexity of human nature and the inappropriateness of categorisation between the disciplines regarding various topics such as security. A complete appreciation and understanding of multidisciplinary texts requires that the reader be well versed in all the disciplines discussed. Ironically therefore, a multidisciplinary approach can have the effect of restricting the audience for which this book is appropriate. That said, students of terrorism and political violence are well advised to read this text. Edgar B. Tembo (University of Sheffield) ______ Tembo, Edgar B. ‘Book Review: Understanding Terrorism and Political Violence: The Life Cycle of Birth, Growth, Transformation and Demise’, Political Studies Review, 7 (September 2009) 3, p. 405.