Subscribe to daily environment news





 

Click for news Click for pictures
National Tree Day

Planet Ark Home


Supreme Court to Hear Cheney Energy Task Force Case
Mail this story to a friend | Printer friendly version

USA: December 18, 2003


WASHINGTON - The U.S. Supreme Court agreed this week to hear Vice President Dick Cheney's arguments for keeping his energy task force papers secret, a battle he has fought in lower courts for more than two years.


The high court said Cheney's Justice Department lawyers could present a detailed explanation of why he should not have to comply with a federal judge's order last year to produce details of White House contacts with the energy industry.

Justice Department lawyers say Cheney is immune to the court order on constitutional, separation-of-powers grounds.

The environmentalist Sierra Club and Judicial Watch government watchdog group sued in 2001 to find out the names and positions of members of the energy task force headed by the vice president that year.

They allege that Cheney, a former energy executive, drafted energy policy by consulting industry executives such as Enron Corp.'s Ken Lay, making them effective members of his task force while leaving environmentalists on the outside.

Cheney was chief executive of energy and construction company Halliburton Co. from 1995 to 2000. His 2001 energy task force produced a policy paper calling for more oil and gas drilling and a revived nuclear power program.

Cheney has acknowledged meeting Lay, but his lawyers say the energy task force was comprised of government officials, not corporate chieftains.

The Supreme Court will hear arguments in the case in the spring next year, with a decision due by the end of June.

Judicial Watch President Tom Fitton said the court's decision to take the case was not surprising "because the executive branch is often given deference. Cases that ought to be left out of court are given a hearing by the justices."

But, Fitton added, "We're confident in the end that the court is going to reject this unprecedented assertion of executive power and executive secrecy."

Sierra Club attorney David Bookbinder said the court's taking the case "will draw attention to the extreme positions the Bush administration has taken, essentially arguing that they are above the law."

There was no immediate reaction from Cheney's office. Over a year ago, U.S. District Court Judge Emmet Sullivan ordered the White House to either produce documents about the energy task force, or provide a detailed list of the documents it was withholding, and why.

The Bush administration appealed the order, even though the case was not completed in the lower court.

The U.S. Court of Appeals earlier this year refused to step in, saying Cheney did not have legal standing to refuse the judge's order.

The Energy Department, the Environmental Protection Agency and other agencies have turned over thousands of pages of documents in the case, but none have come from the White House.

Justice Department lawyers argued that judicial power cannot extend to ordering the executive branch to disclose details about the way the president gets advice - such as advice on energy policy.

Judicial Watch countered that Cheney's claims to immunity were laughable after a 1997 Supreme Court decision that discovery could proceed against then-President Bill Clinton in a case brought by sexual-harassment accuser Paula Jones.


Story by Susan Cornwell


REUTERS NEWS SERVICE

Reuters



© 2008 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
top

 
18 DEC 2003
ENVIRONMENT
NEWS

AUSTRALIA:
Australia to Deploy Armed Ship to Protect Fisheries

BELGIUM:
EU Insists Its Support for Kyoto Policy Unwavering

BRAZIL:
UK Greenpeace activist found dead in Amazon

DENMARK:
Fire Threatens Fish in Europe's Largest Aquarium

IRAN:
Iran to Sign Snap Nuclear Check Protocol Thursday

ITALY:
UN urges US to unlock North Korea food aid

JAPAN:
Japan and Russia to Discuss Pipeline Further

SOUTH KOREA:
Hyundai Mtr to invest $590 mln in cleaner vehicles

SWITZERLAND:
UN Weather Body Says No El Nino in Sight for 2004

USA:
High Court to Hear Mexican Truck Environmental Case

USA:
Court Reinstates Mad Cow Suit Against USDA

USA:
Thirst for LNG Imports Focus of Meeting

USA:
US consumers will not shun biotech wheat - Kraft

USA:
EPA Offers Plan to Cut Mercury from Power Plants

USA:
US nuclear industry eyes new reactor projects

USA:
Supreme Court to Hear Cheney Energy Task Force Case



previous day
today's news
next day