Britain is protecting the biggest heroin crop of all time
By CRAIG MURRAYLast updated at 20:45 21 July 2007
This week the 64th British soldier to die in Afghanistan, Corporal Mike Gilyeat, was buried. All the right things were said about this brave soldier, just as, on current trends, they will be said about one or more of his colleagues who follow him next week.
The alarming escalation of the casualty rate among British soldiers in Afghanistan ? up to ten per cent ? led to discussion this week on whether it could be fairly compared to casualty rates in the Second World War.
Scroll down for more...
Killing fields: Farmers in Afghanistan gather an opium crop which will be made into heroin
But the key question is this: what are our servicemen dying for? There are glib answers to that: bringing democracy and development to Afghanistan, supporting the government of President Hamid Karzai in its attempt to establish order in the country, fighting the Taliban and preventing the further spread of radical Islam into Pakistan.
But do these answers stand up to close analysis?
There has been too easy an acceptance of the lazy notion that the war in Afghanistan is the 'good' war, while the war in Iraq is the 'bad' war, the blunder. The origins of this view are not irrational. There was a logic to attacking Afghanistan after 9/11.
Afghanistan was indeed the headquarters of Osama Bin Laden and his organisation, who had been installed and financed there by the CIA to fight the Soviets from 1979 until 1989. By comparison, the attack on Iraq ? which was an enemy of Al Qaeda and no threat to us ? was plainly irrational in terms of the official justification.
So the attack on Afghanistan has enjoyed a much greater sense of public legitimacy. But the operation to remove Bin Laden was one thing. Six years of occupation are clearly another.
Head of the Afghan armed forces: General Abdul Rashid Dostrum
Few seem to turn a hair at the officially expressed view that our occupation of Iraq may last for decades.
Lib Dem leader Menzies Campbell has declared, fatuously, that the Afghan war is 'winnable'.
Afghanistan was not militarily winnable by the British Empire at the height of its supremacy. It was not winnable by Darius or Alexander, by Shah, Tsar or Great Moghul. It could not be subdued by 240,000 Soviet troops. But what, precisely, are we trying to win?
In six years, the occupation has wrought one massive transformation in Afghanistan, a development so huge that it has increased Afghan GDP by 66 per cent and constitutes 40 per cent of the entire economy. That is a startling achievement, by any standards. Yet we are not trumpeting it. Why not?
The answer is this. The achievement is the highest harvests of opium the world has ever seen.
The Taliban had reduced the opium crop to precisely nil. I would not advocate their methods for doing this, which involved lopping bits, often vital bits, off people. The Taliban were a bunch of mad and deeply unpleasant religious fanatics. But one of the things they were vehemently against was opium.
That is an inconvenient truth that our spin has managed to obscure. Nobody has denied the sincerity of the Taliban's crazy religious zeal, and they were as unlikely to sell you heroin as a bottle of Johnnie Walker.
They stamped out the opium trade, and impoverished and drove out the drug warlords whose warring and rapacity had ruined what was left of the country after the Soviet war.
That is about the only good thing you can say about the Taliban; there are plenty of very bad things to say about them. But their suppression of the opium trade and the drug barons is undeniable fact.
Now we are occupying the country, that has changed. According to the United Nations, 2006 was the biggest opium harvest in history, smashing the previous record by 60 per cent. This year will be even bigger.
Our economic achievement in Afghanistan goes well beyond the simple production of raw opium. In fact Afghanistan no longer exports much raw opium at all. It has succeeded in what our international aid efforts urge every developing country to do. Afghanistan has gone into manufacturing and 'value-added' operations.
It now exports not opium, but heroin. Opium is converted into heroin on an industrial scale, not in kitchens but in factories. Millions of gallons of the chemicals needed for this process are shipped into Afghanistan by tanker. The tankers and bulk opium lorries on the way to the factories share the roads, improved by American aid, with Nato troops.
How can this have happened, and on this scale? The answer is simple. The four largest players in the heroin business are all senior members of the Afghan government ? the government that our soldiers are fighting and dying to protect.
When we attacked Afghanistan, America bombed from the air while the CIA paid, armed and equipped the dispirited warlord drug barons ? especially those grouped in the Northern Alliance ? to do the ground occupation. We bombed the Taliban and their allies into submission, while the warlords moved in to claim the spoils. Then we made them ministers.
President Karzai is a good man. He has never had an opponent killed, which may not sound like much but is highly unusual in this region and possibly unique in an Afghan leader. But nobody really believes he is running the country. He asked America to stop its recent bombing campaign in the south because it was leading to an increase in support for the Taliban. The United States simply ignored him. Above all, he has no control at all over the warlords among his ministers and governors, each of whom runs his own kingdom and whose primary concern is self-enrichment through heroin.
My knowledge of all this comes from my time as British Ambassador in neighbouring Uzbekistan from 2002 until 2004. I stood at the Friendship Bridge at Termez in 2003 and watched the Jeeps with blacked-out windows bringing the heroin through from Afghanistan, en route to Europe.
I watched the tankers of chemicals roaring into Afghanistan.
Yet I could not persuade my country to do anything about it. Alexander Litvinenko ? the former agent of the KGB, now the FSB, who died in London last November after being poisoned with polonium 210 ? had suffered the same frustration over the same topic.
There are a number of theories as to why Litvinenko had to flee Russia. The most popular blames his support for the theory that FSB agents planted bombs in Russian apartment blocks to stir up anti-Chechen feeling.
But the truth is that his discoveries about the heroin trade were what put his life in danger. Litvinenko was working for the KGB in St Petersburg in 2001 and 2002. He became concerned at the vast amounts of heroin coming from Afghanistan, in particular from the fiefdom of the (now) Head of the Afghan armed forces, General Abdul Rashid Dostum, in north and east Afghanistan.
Dostum is an Uzbek, and the heroin passes over the Friendship Bridge from Afghanistan to Uzbekistan, where it is taken over by President Islam Karimov's people. It is then shipped up the railway line, in bales of cotton, to St Petersburg and Riga.
The heroin Jeeps run from General Dostum to President Karimov. The UK, United States and Germany have all invested large sums in donating the most sophisticated detection and screening equipment to the Uzbek customs centre at Termez to stop the heroin coming through.
But the convoys of Jeeps running between Dostum and Karimov are simply waved around the side of the facility.
Litvinenko uncovered the St Petersburg end and was stunned by the involvement of the city authorities, local police and security services at the most senior levels. He reported in detail to President Vladimir Putin. Putin is, of course, from St Petersburg, and the people Litvinenko named were among Putin's closest political allies. That is why Litvinenko, having miscalculated badly, had to flee Russia.
I had as little luck as Litvinenko in trying to get official action against this heroin trade. At the St Petersburg end he found those involved had the top protection. In Afghanistan, General Dostum is vital to Karzai's coalition, and to the West's pretence of a stable, democratic government.
Opium is produced all over Afghanistan, but especially in the north and north-east ? Dostum's territory. Again, our Government's spin doctors have tried hard to obscure this fact and make out that the bulk of the heroin is produced in the tiny areas of the south under Taliban control. But these are the most desolate, infertile rocky areas. It is a physical impossibility to produce the bulk of the vast opium harvest there.
That General Dostum is head of the Afghan armed forces and Deputy Minister of Defence is in itself a symbol of the bankruptcy of our policy. Dostum is known for tying opponents to tank tracks and running them over. He crammed prisoners into metal containers in the searing sun, causing scores to die of heat and thirst.
Since we brought 'democracy' to Afghanistan, Dostum ordered an MP who annoyed him to be pinned down while he attacked him. The sad thing is that Dostum is probably not the worst of those comprising the Karzai government, or the biggest drug smuggler among them.
Our Afghan policy is still victim to Tony Blair's simplistic world view and his childish division of all conflicts into 'good guys' and 'bad guys'. The truth is that there are seldom any good guys among those vying for power in a country such as Afghanistan. To characterise the Karzai government as good guys is sheer nonsense.
Why then do we continue to send our soldiers to die in Afghanistan? Our presence in Afghanistan and Iraq is the greatest recruiting sergeant for Islamic militants. As the great diplomat, soldier and adventurer Lieutenant-Colonel Sir Alexander Burnes pointed out before his death in the First Afghan War in 1841, there is no point in a military campaign in Afghanistan as every time you beat them, you just swell their numbers. Our only real achievement to date is falling street prices for heroin in London.
Remember this article next time you hear a politician calling for more troops to go into Afghanistan. And when you hear of another brave British life wasted there, remember you can add to the casualty figures all the young lives ruined, made miserable or ended by heroin in the UK.
They, too, are casualties of our Afghan policy.
Share this article:
Here's what readers have had to say so far. Why not add your thoughts below?
The problems in Afghanistan must be resolved by the people of Afghanistan. Our troops should be employed in destroying the poppy crop and the facilities for processing heroin and then we leave. All Afghans in our country should be returned, with a cash bonus, to enable them to settle back; and all Afghans must cooperate together to bring their country into the civilized world. We cannot solve their problems!
- John, Spalding, England, 22/7/2007 09:04
If the mighty Russian military was unable to defeat the Taliban, what chance has NATO got to do the same with a much smaller force. It's a lost cause, if you ask me.
- Cww, Suffolk, 22/7/2007 08:28
**yourComments**
- **name**, **townAndCountry**, **creationDate**
Add your comment
FEMAIL TODAY
- We ARE divorcing, confirms Madonna as she faces £150m payout to Guy Her spokeswoman today announced the end of the seven-year marriage
- Lourdes wants to spend more time in the U.S., but where will Rocco and David call home? The Ritchie children face an uncertain future
- Nice tie, Posh, but where did you leave your shirt? Victoria Beckham tried an avant garde look for her new denim collection launch in Dusseldorf
- Seve 'stable' after surgeons successfully remove brain tumour in 12-hour op The Spanish golfer is recovering in intensive care in Madrid
- Health fears for Sky's Kay Burley as she fails to turn up for work after collapsing at the end of yesterday's show The anchorwoman didn't appear at work today
- Get a grip, Louis: Should ANYONE from X Factor's Girlband really be stuffing their face with chips? Not for Phoebe her rivals' diet-and-gym overhauls
- Attack of the clones: Demi Moore and lookalike Courteney Cox in red-carpet face-off After Madonna and Lohan, another pair of A-list doppelgängers
- What a Carrie-on at M&S: Hundreds queue as Sex And The Tacky dresses hit high street SATC's acclaimed stylist Patricia Field launched the new range in London
- Kate Moss reveals her strange lumpy wrist on a night out in London A peculiar bulge diverted attention from her exit as she left a club in an unusually demure dress
- Never too old for puppy love: Ageing rocker Ronnie Wood and new girlfriend take their dog for a walk The Stone and Ekaterina wore huge great smiles
- It's all white on the night as Christina Aguilera blazes back into the spotlight The singer looked incredible before the gig and during
- '4x4' Ulrika: 'The truth about weekend dads - and I should know' ULRIKA JONSSON writes with astonishing honesty about juggling her unconventional family
- Stunning beauty queen died in agony after 15 doctors failed to spot she was seriously ill Mady Benson suffered a fatal heart attack after a catalogue of errors
- WAG circus cost us the last World Cup, says Rio Ferdinand The footballer comes clean about the extraordinary side-show that let down England
- Supermarket fuel wars: Petrol falls below £1 per litre for the first time since December
- Slap in the face for home-owners as Nationwide fails to pass on emergency cut in interest rate
- Unemployment to hit THREE MILLION 'within a year' as total rises at fastest rate for over 17 years
- Airport admits 'strip search' body scanners WILL show people naked
- Two arrested after teenager launches internet hunt for his mother's killers
- Coma victim able to speak again after pioneering magnetic field therapy - and his first words are 'Help me'
- Average woman puts on two stone between meeting husband and middle age
- The moment a bomber walked in: Islam convert caught on CCTV as he brings terror to a crowded restaurant
- The BBC will tackle Islam differently to Christianity, admits its Director General
- Jury hears tape of Hannah Foster's last terrified words with man accused of raping and killing her
- Prescott admits dislike for 'snobby' Cherie Blair in new documentary
- Sleep deprivation in Britain is a MYTH - we've never slept so well, claims scientist
- Woman crushed to death after forgetting handbrake then leaping in front of runaway car
- Award-winning kennel owner covered up death of millionaire surgeon's dog after it was savaged by two bull terriers
- Caught on camera: The eight-year-old 'Artful Dodger' who stole thousands - but is too young to face charges
- 'I paid my tax and all I got was this lousy wall': The first slogan to be etched on £3,000 wall... built especially for graffiti artists
- Virgin passenger plane 'sent 70 miles off course into thunderstorms... to test the skills of a trainee air traffic controller'
- We'd like a bigger council house please, say family of 13 who live on £27,000-a-year benefits
- Dozens of children treated for TB after outbreak at Knightsbridge nursery
- Government unveils 'Big Brother' plan to log calls and emails of EVERY person in Britain
- Mother brings son's ashes to court to prove he couldn't have sold illegal vehicle
- Payout for businesswoman hurt in airport slip - because her 200 pairs of shoes are now useless
- Builder saves lives of twins by plucking them from garden pond and giving them kiss of life
- Children and babies as young as one treated for alcohol abuse
- New poll gives Obama huge 14-point lead ahead of final TV debate with McCain
- Britain could have first 'green Christmas' as climate change warms autumn
- MORE HEADLINES
- 'Hospital deceived me on the death of my beauty queen wife'
- Alarm as Australia's beach girls paint phone numbers on their skin to attract boys
- Teenage girl admits kissing Emmerdale star Ben Freeman before 'rape'
- Airport admits 'strip search' body scanners WILL show people naked
- Teenage girl 'gang raped and covered in burning caustic soda'
- Interest rates set to plunge to 2% in desperate bid to kickstart crippled economy
- Lecturer caught naked in bed with schoolgirl walks free from court
- Slap in the face for homeowners as Nationwide fails to pass on emergency cut in interest rate
- Banks shareholders WILL be paid dividends after a year following revolt over rescue deal
- Unemployment to hit THREE MILLION 'within a year' as it rises at fastest rate for 17 years
- Pictured: Fat Boy, the pony who got drunk on fermented apples and fell into a swimming pool
- Builder saves lives of twins by plucking them from garden pond and giving them kiss of life
- Beckham housekeeper's son is third arrested as family deny 'theft of dresses and football boots' from mansion
- Town hall bosses scrap 'cash cow' speed cameras
- Black police officer 'wore traditional African robe to work in protest over dress code'
- Woman crushed to death after forgetting handbrake then leaping in front of runaway car
- Murdered teen Hannah Foster 'made desperate silent 999 mobile call as she was abducted - but was cut off'
- Caught on camera: The 'Artful Dodger' aged eight who stole thousands... but is too young to face charges
- Primary school in lock-down after 4ft 'puma' is spotted
- The BBC will tackle Islam differently to Christianity, admits its Director General
- MOST READ IN DETAIL
EDITOR'S SIX OF THE BEST
-
Pictured: The music fan who played banjo on operating table while doctors carried out surgery on his brain
-
The eco-town where they only turn on the streetlights if you phone and tell them you want to go out
-
Survivor of U-boat attack is laid to rest in sunken battleship in which 800 of his comrades died
-
How tycoon Steve Wynn made £15m out of TEARING his priceless Picasso
-
Welcome to world's first 'no star' hotel - where guests sleep in an atomic bunker with no windows
-
Pictured: The British teenager who shattered a 436-year men-only tradition to win a place at the Spanish Riding School


Part of the Daily Mail, The Mail on Sunday, Evening Standard & Metro Media Group
If people want to kill themselves with drugs so be it. But stop putting our decent boys lives at risk to fight for it.
- Jacqui Weems, Southampton, 22/7/2007 09:05