Support NeoGAF

bouc_emissaire · Apr 5, 2007

Well... stupid because it's stupid to compare a FPS with a "Tactical Espionnage Action" ( © Kojima) and with a funky Naughty Dog game.
But... i think it's fun, no war here.
Just to compare the biggest PC game of 2007-2008 with two of the biggest PS3 games of 2007-2008.

Technically, Crysis is a beast, but i think that MGS4 and Uncharted still have THE art direction (IMHO).
The lighting in Crysis looks so real... (like in GTHD), but the lighting in Uncharted and MGS4 is so gorgeous and charming.
Crysis has got the very high rez' textures, but Uncharted will have incredible characters animations, an MGS4 will have an incredible AI.
Different approaches.

Certainly three big games. Peace.

OatmealMu · Apr 5, 2007

bouc_emissaire
Who Compares, Wins

Now I get it.

TemplaerDude · Apr 5, 2007

Variable · Apr 5, 2007

Almost as dumb as trying to compare Saints Row and GTA 4.

DSN2K · Apr 5, 2007

CRYSIS >>>>>>>>>>>> whatever PS3/360 can do.

dogonfire · Apr 5, 2007

The only logical conclusion here is that Crysis is a hoax.

Speevy · Apr 5, 2007

Crysis wins.

Kangu · Apr 5, 2007

Crysis embarasses the next gen again.

ghst · Apr 5, 2007

Hey, Let's compare various builds of questionable footage of largely unrelated games on seperate platforms, that'll make for some sweet discussion.

NARUTO WOULD SOOOO PWN GOKU.

Remedy · Apr 5, 2007

Don't all overreact/get offended at the same time.

Speevy · Apr 5, 2007

The PS3 shots actually serve the system well in the lighting department, but Crysis slaughters them in detail.

Wollan · Apr 5, 2007

Uncharted's advantage will become much clearer when everything actually moves.

Ranger X · Apr 5, 2007

At least everybody with a PS3 will enjoy MGS4 and Uncharted at their top shape form...

Totalriot · Apr 5, 2007

You did find some nice pictures to compare to each other.

How big would be the gap in like 4 years? As big as PS3/X360 to Wii? Or even bigger?

Stink · Apr 5, 2007

Crysis embarrasses your graphics card.

revolverjgw · Apr 5, 2007

My fanboy pee-pee measurer must preface this by pointing out that MGS4 will be much better game than Crysis, as MGS3 was to Far Cry, but it can't compare graphically. It's actually kind of disappointing to me from technical point of view. Still great art though.

element · Apr 5, 2007

where can I download video of someone playing MGS4 or Uncharted???? If you have a link, please post it, I can't seem to find one.
thanks

Speevy · Apr 5, 2007

Wollan said:
Uncharted's advantage will become much clearer when everything actually moves.

Over Crysis? Well-animated or not, it's not even in the same league as Crysis with respect to detail.

And I love the way Uncharted looks. One of the best looking games on any console.

Y2Kev · Apr 5, 2007

Crysis is an unfair control cause it only runs on supacomputas and they cost like 125 grand!

rage1973 · Apr 5, 2007

Wollan said:
Crysis's advantage will become much clearer when you figure in physics and destructable environments

Fixed

Dave1988 · Apr 5, 2007

ghst said:
NARUTO WOULD SOOOO PWN GOKU.

Oh no, you didn-

DBZDF Assemble!!

;p

Oblivion · Apr 5, 2007

Aren't they 2 different types of games?

Which looks better, Lair or LBP?

Danne-Danger · Apr 5, 2007

IMHO MGS4 -almost- holds it's own against Crysis, however, when the physics starts moving Crysis just blows everything else out of the water (including your current rig).

Looking forward to seeing some screens of the the alleged "jungle zone" in MGS.

OatmealMu · Apr 5, 2007

Oblivion said:
Aren't they 2 different types of games?

Which looks better, Lair or LBP?

Pirates of the Caribbean

on the Wii.

Gantz · Apr 5, 2007

Crysis wins. MGS yet again uses bland washed out graphics and textures.

Cruceh · Apr 5, 2007

rage1973 said:
Fixed

I think he meant that nobody's computer can run the game at that level of detail at a constant 60fps.

Anyway, wow at the brown in MGS4.

Wollan · Apr 5, 2007

One thing is certain, there's a lot of good looking graphics in this thread.

Surreal · Apr 5, 2007

Whenever I turn on Discovery HD I say to myself, "This looks more real than real life." Crisis gives me the same vibe, now if they could get rid of the plastic look over some plants and make the humans look more real. Maybe next-gen.

edit; I hope people aren't serious, Crysis recommends 1.5 GB of RAM to play smoothly, there's no way PS3 can compete.

DIrtyWeasel · Apr 5, 2007

MGS4 looks almost monochrome, everything is brown and grey.

vertopci · Apr 5, 2007

DIrtyWeasel said:
MGS4 looks almost monochrome, everything is brown and grey.

I really like the monochrome look.

Personally I think MGS4 looks better than Crysis

Pistolero · Apr 5, 2007

Stink said:
Crysis embarrasses your graphics card.

:lol

C4Lukins · Apr 5, 2007

Wollan said:
One thing is certain, there's a lot of good looking graphics in this thread.

That is half true.

xabre · Apr 5, 2007

Crysis rips them to shreads...not even close actually.

raYne · Apr 5, 2007

DIrtyWeasel said:
MGS4 looks almost monochrome, everything is brown and grey.

That's my problem with it. Though I don't see it as that big of a deal, considering that all the media's pretty much from the same area. I hope to God the whole game doesn't look like that though.

Red Blaster · Apr 5, 2007

Crysis looks great but if Far Cry is anything to go by, it'll play like bird doo-doo.

Pimpwerx · Apr 5, 2007

Jesus, Crysis is even better than the Uncharted concept render (first pic with the jeep). That's just not fair. :lol PEACE.

WARCOCK · Apr 5, 2007

Wollan said:
Uncharted's advantage will become much clearer when everything actually moves.

There is no advantage. Crysis pwns it on the right machine. end of story.

vpance · Apr 5, 2007

How is Crysis able to look so good? It's not really a hardware thing because they said it would run decently on a Core 2 / X2 cpu and a high end DX9 card like 7900gtx. I guess it's a memory thing? With PC's having so much more memory than consoles for more textures. The Crysis engine devs must be some of the best in the world.

Lince · Apr 5, 2007

Crysis recommends 1.5 GB of RAM to play smoothly

well Vista recommends 2 GB of RAM to run smoothly... and Directx-10 Crysis must run on top of it too so.. 4 GB confirmed?

:lol

aeolist · Apr 5, 2007

Uncharted certainly has my attention. Is there any info out on how it'll play?

Wollan · Apr 5, 2007

WARCOCK said:
There is no advantage. Crysis pwns it on the right machine. end of story.

Don't misunderstand me. I'm not saying Uncharted looks better than Crysis, I'm just saying that Uncharted's biggest graphical feature is the actual animation and how it flows.

Yoboman · Apr 5, 2007

It's not even safe to say MGS4 looks as good as many of those pics anymore. It's also not fair to compare cause MGS4 may be as linear as previous MGS games, it may have highly static environments. Crysis does not. The Naughty Dog comparison is fairer. Crysis wins.

rage1973 · Apr 5, 2007

vertopci said:
I really like the monochrome look.

Personally I think MGS4 looks better than Crysis

You probably prefer black and white TV over color too right?

Wollan · Apr 5, 2007

aeolist said:
Uncharted certainly has my attention. Is there any info out on how it'll play?

Combat is kinda like Gears in that there is a actual cover system. Jumping is like Zelda in that it's automatic depending on ledge..etc. The control is supposed to feel really responsive but still have a feeling of weight and realism to it. Every time you lean up against a wall or do whatever it looks different. If you run a lot the main character will start shaking, breathing hard and whatnot. 3000 separate animation for the main character when the game ships compared to Jak which had 200.

aeolist · Apr 5, 2007

Wollan said:
Combat is kinda like Gears in that there is a actual cover system. Jumping is like Zelda in that it's automatic depending on ledge..etc. The control is supposed to feel really responsive but still have a feeling of weight and realism to it.

Didn't they show some melee combat stuff in the first demo video? Is it more like an action-adventure or a third person shooter?

DIrtyWeasel · Apr 5, 2007

vertopci said:
I really like the monochrome look.

Personally I think MGS4 looks better than Crysis

I've always been a sucker for colors and high saturation. I probably played too many Nintendo games. I like green trees, blue skies... stuff like that.
Brown and grey worked fine for the atmosphere in games like Gears of War and Resident Evil 4. I haven't seen 300, but i'm sure it worked for that movie.

Greg · Apr 5, 2007

WARCOCK said:
There is no advantage. Crysis pwns it on the right machine. end of story.

I'm not so sure about that - knowing ND, the animations will be amazing.

graphics and physics easily go to Crysis, but I honestly don't think it'll be close when it comes to animations - that's where ND has always shined.

fse · Apr 5, 2007

Crysis > *

Rorschach · Apr 5, 2007

Small, squished screens ftw!

There is lots that those screens don't show that an hd video would. It's not just textures.

Crysis wins.

Pimpwerx said:
Jesus, Crysis is even better than the Uncharted concept render (first pic with the jeep). That's just not fair. PEACE.

:lol I didn't know that was a render. Awesome.

gregor7777 · Apr 5, 2007

Red Blaster said:
Crysis looks great but if Far Cry is anything to go by, it'll play like bird doo-doo.

Far Cry on the PC was good, on the consoles not so much.

Support NeoGAF

The stupid comparison : Crysis vs MGS4 and Uncharted (no 56k)

Who Compares, Wins

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Banned

Banned

thanks for the laugh

Banned

Banned

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Banned

TLG Fan Caretaker Est. 2009

Member

Member

Fetishing muscular manly men in skintight hosery

Member

Member

Banned

Banned

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Junior Member

Banned

Member

Member

Member

Banned

Member

Banned

Banned

Member

Member

Member

Member

Banned

Member

Member

Member

Member

Banned

Similar threads